Disclosure: I received a copy of this book free of charge for review purposes only. Receipt of a book does not guarantee a review or endorsement.
Birdie works at a remote Alaskan lodge, leaving her young daughter alone while she works late for tips. Works late and parties too, while she’s at it. When she takes it too far one night, she’s moved to the day shift. There she meets Arthur, a quiet man fond of chamomile tea, who lives alone in a cabin even more remote than the lodge. Arthur is barely seen in town, and people try and warn her off him, but she is seduced by the idea of living a simpler life. One where she and her daughter can leave modern life behind.
First off, Eowyn Ivey writes beautifully about the nature and landscape of Alaska. I can’t fault her on that front and would 100% read a non-fiction nature book by her if she chose to write one.
A life in Alaska means always being prepared to meet a bear. Encounters are peppered throughout the story leading up to the reveal. It makes total sense to create a myth around a bear in this land. A story about what happens when humans step into the territory of another species, one who has no choice but to co-exist. The strength is in the bear’s story, but most is from the perspective of other characters, and I was disappointed it didn’t explore that side more. What would it be like to exist trapped between two lives, doomed to hurt or be hurt?
I loved The Snow Child, but Black Woods, Blue Sky failed to make the same mark. The characters felt a bit basic. Birdie is your stereotypical uneducated, single mother, who likes to drink and party with the guys, while neglecting her daughter. There was zero chemistry between her and Arthur, making me feel she was just moving in to avoid rent and responsibilities. I didn’t really care about what happened to her.
When Birdie was pregnant, she’d imagined raising a miniature version of herself, but instead she’d given birth to a stranger she was just beginning to get to know.
There isn’t much mystery about what’s going on. In The Snow Child you were left wondering what was real, but there’s no such ambiguity here, even if it tries to make Emaleen question what she saw. The fact that Warren spells it all out quite early on, takes away any doubt.
It’s being pitched as a Beauty and the Beast retelling as well, which leads the reader to assume certain things. It’s honestly not the same story, more very loosely inspired and given an Alaskan twist. Birdie doesn’t meet a beast. She meets a quiet and awkward man who keeps to himself, for good reason. She inserts herself into his life, and only finds out the truth when it’s too late.
I did feel sorry for poor baby Arthur, stolen from his mother by well-meaning people who thought they were doing the right thing. Perhaps this is the crux of the book. Birdie should be allowed to raise her child even if onlookers think she’s doing a bad job. And there’s no point in trying to tame a wild thing.
Emaleen was around five or six for the majority of the story, and I personally dislike adult fiction from a young child’s point-of-view, so this definitely took away from some of my enjoyment. However, she’s an antidote to her doesn’t-give-a-crap mother and important for the ending, which I’ll admit was incredibly moving.
A memory stirred, fragmented and blurry and maybe not even real. Her mom coming home from the mountains with her face burnished by wind and sun, her hair wild. Tart blueberries pouring out of a canteen instead of water. She’d spent the night alone on a rock, she said. There had been so many stars. And a giant’s teeth. A ring of mushrooms where the witches and fairies danced. Caribous marching across the sky with their antlers bleeding.
I’m sure others will get a lot more out of this book than I did. It would certainly raise some questions for a book group to discuss. Black Woods, Blue Sky is published by Tinder Press and will be available in hardback, ebook and audiobook editions from 4th February 2025. Thanks go to the publisher for providing a copy for review via NetGalley.
Goodreads | StoryGraph
Amazon* | Waterstones* | Hive | Wordery | Blackwell’s* | Bookshop.org*
*indicates an affiliate link
Related posts
2 Comments
Leave a ReplyCancel reply
This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.






Sorry to hear this one didn’t live up to THE SNOW CHILD for you! I’ve got in on hold now and was hoping it might recapture some of that magic… fingers crossed I’ll still enjoy it, but I’ll temper my expectations.
No chemistry? I differ in my thoughts… the chemistry was too much, to my mind. For me, in the end, this one equaled The Snow Child. Though one third of the way through I thought not.