Disclosure: I received a copy of this book free of charge for review purposes only. Receipt of a book does not guarantee a review or endorsement.

the black bird oracleThe Black Bird Oracle takes place after the All Souls trilogy and therefore this review may contain spoilers for the previous books.

Diana and Matthew’s children are about to turn seven, the age the congregation test magical abilities in witches. The last thing Diana wants is a repeat of her treatment at the hands of Peter Knox, and she vows not to let them near the twins. Then a mysterious message is delivered, from someone claiming to be family. Family Diana thought were all dead.

I was excited to return to Matthew and Diana and see how they were doing, but I think it’s about time I stopped reading this series. The trilogy was great, and it tied things up nicely, and so this book didn’t feel necessary. I wouldn’t have minded if this was a short, slice of life novella taking in the family’s domesticity and learning about the kids’ powers, but instead we got a long-winded start to a new series.

First off, I did like the sentient oracle card deck and Becca’s spooky doll. I was intrigued by the mysterious bone ring, but nothing ever comes of it, at least not in this book. I liked the idea of the memory bottles, and they maybe gave a bit of credence to why some of the stuff doesn’t come up in the earlier books.

Alas, I found it hard to believe that throughout everything, Diana would have this huge extended family of witches that she had no knowledge of. There was a completed trilogy about Diana discovering her past and learning to use her powers, yet her we are again; Diana learning about her family’s past and learning higher magic.

It starts off with mama-bear Diana wanting to protect her kids. Fair enough, but then she disappears off to see the family she’s never met before, leaving her children. And she just seems more concerned about getting mixed up in petty grudges involving people who have been dead for centuries, and learning dark magic except it’s not dark magic, or maybe it is. Poor children were forgotten about pretty quickly.

Maybe Harkness wanted to write a cosy but was under pressure to continue with her bestselling series. There is a lot of tea drinking going on, and the action stops frequently for slice of life moments. There’s a whole segue into the history of the Salem witches too. I just wasn’t sure what this book wanted to be, and I don’t think it hooked me enough to want to read any more in this series.

The Black Bird Oracle is published by Headline and is out now in hardback, ebook and audiobook editions. Thanks go to the publisher for providing a copy for review.

Goodreads | StoryGraph

Amazon* | Waterstones* | Hive | Wordery | Blackwell’s* | Bookshop.org*

*indicates an affiliate link

What do other bloggers think?

Caffeinated Reviewer | Leah’s Books | Bookshelf Fantasies | A Take from Two Cities