For a while, Jacob believed his grandfather’s tales of the home he grew up in, on a remote island off the coast of Wales. He even had a collection of photographs to back them up. But Jacob soon grew out of the fairy tales, seeing manipulation in all the photographs, until one day, his grandfather is attacked. In the shadows, Jacob sees something. Something that may just prove his grandfather wasn’t crazy. Now everyone thinks Jacob is crazy. With agreement from his psychiatrist, Jacob sets off to Cairnholm Island to visit the place where the stories started.
It was a wonderful idea to build up a story around vintage photographs. The photos are genuine (anyone with an interest in the history of photography will know that people liked manipulating them from the start) and the characters are born out of them. In places, it felt a bit forced and the recurring photos of Emma were obviously not the same girl, but overall, it lifted the book from a simple adventure to something a bit special. Many of the photos are incredibly creepy and those at book group who read ebooks said the unexpected nature of them made them more of a shock when they just appeared on the screen!
The story itself isn’t particularly unique. There’s a home for children with unique powers, even if they are a little quaint (and seemingly pointless at times). There’s an is-he-mad-or-are-they-real plotline. There’s a Narnia-esque doorway to another world and a boy who doesn’t have friends at home but discovers them where he never expected. But I guess these things have become popular tropes because they do work.
The language wasn’t always consistent with the period. The peculiar children certainly didn’t speak like they were in the 40s. I also spent a lot of time trying to work out how the time-defying postal system worked. It’s probably a book best not over-analysed; an otherwise easy and fun read.
I had thought it was a standalone book so it was a bit disappointing when it didn’t really end. It’s clearly set up for a second instalment (out January 2014) and I’m not sure how the photographs are going to work when it’s not about discovery and history. Jacob kept relating the things he was seeing back to his grandfather’s photos or the ones he found in the house. It’s can’t carry on like that; will they be taking photos as they go? I will probably end up reading it just to find out.
I gave Miss Peregrine’s Home for Peculiar Children 7/10 at book group and I’ve been dithering over a star rating. The text itself is probably only 3 stars for me but the photography is a huge bonus…so 4 it is.
Subscribe via Email
If you happen to be reading articles about Kazuo Ishiguro/Klara and the Sun having not read (or watched) Never Let… https://t.co/Sql7aCHQ6VFollow
Forgot how hard fishing is at the start of Stardew Valley. At least they've added a training rod so I have some cha… https://t.co/3lOs92nZRmFollow
Today he would become a god. His mother had told him so. The opening line may seem like something any mother would tell her son, but in the case of Serapio, his mother truly believes he will become the Crow God reborn. She blinds him,…
The day Bree gets accepted into an early college placement at UNC, is the day her mother dies. The last words they spoke were of anger. Unable to deal with her dad’s grief on top of her own, Bree goes ahead with the placement. Once…
Alex Stern does not belong at Yale. When she awakes as the sole survivor of a multiple homicide, presumed a drug deal gone wrong, she is given an unlikely offer. Come to Yale, join the House of Lethe and oversee the rituals of the other…
A Beautifully Foolish Endeavor
Just let me dust off this blog thing, I have a review for you! One of my anticipated reads released during lockdown was the follow-up to An Absolutely Remarkable Thing. If you read that, of course will will be dying to know what happened to…