With cosy fantasy being a relatively new arrival on the subgenre block, there’s a lot of confusion about what exactly it is. It’s also a Popsugar Reading Challenge prompt this year, and the variations in the cosiness of the reads is huge. I have therefore decided that all fantasy exists on a spectrum of grim to cosy. Until the day someone manages to write cosy grimdark (I mean, John Wiswell managed to make horror cosy, so it’s possible).
What makes a book cosy?
✔ Kind characters…
✔ … who are not killed off.
✔ The dog* definitely does not die.
✔ It’s not about saving the whole world.
✔ They probably drink a lot of tea or coffee. And there’s cake.
What makes a book grim?
✔ Characters are selfish, cruel, or generally unlikable.
✔ If you do like them, they will die.
✔ Lots of other people die too…
✔ … and the dog*.
✔ The whole world is doomed.
✔ There’s no time to stop for dinner because something terrible is happening.
*The dog is interchangeable for any lovable animal companion. In the grimmest of books, they are too good to exist in the terrible world, and therefore the author must kill them off or risk looking too nice.
So obviously a lot of books fall between these (completely unofficial) definitions.
Presenting the Cosyometer
Or Cozyometer if you’re American.

I first made the graphic because I was describing Paws and Portals as more cosy than grim, and I wanted a way to show where it fell. But then I thought other people might like to make their own, and what better time to share than during Wyrd and Wonder.
I have provided graphics with both spellings. The ZIP file also contains portrait versions, the landscape versions without the book rectangles, and the thermometer image by itself (SVG and PNG).
UK Cosyometer | US Cozyometer | Download ZIP File
License: These graphics are being provided free for personal use and for the purpose of promoting books, games, films or other creative endeavours. You cannot sell the graphics or upload them to stock image sites. Attribution isn’t necessary but is always appreciated.
Whereabouts is your comfort zone on the Cosyometer? Lately, I’ve been reaching for much more cosy reads, but usually I’d say I read somewhere in the middle. Not too grim, not too cosy…
Related posts
20 Comments
Leave a ReplyCancel reply
This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.






Such a cute post, Ellie! Personally, I was so shocked when I read Emily Wilde bc everyone was saying it’s cozy… and I guess the book does match up with your criteria for what’s cozy, but I actually thought it was a lot darker than what people were making it out to be. The scene with Emily’s finger was so wild. 😂 The vibes were definitely vibing though, and I did want to go camping after I read the books… 😄
I had a bit of trouble thinking of books for the cosy end. I agree Emily Wylde has a dark streak – that’s kinda what I love about it. I think it probably comes across as cosy to those who read the grimmer end of the scale though.
This is brilliant. And what a good way of demonstrating the vibe of your new book!
I haven’t been reading a lot of new SFF lately, except for rereading Pratchett. Now that I’m thinking about it, even though Discworld is a comfort read for me and they’re definitely not bloody-grim à la GRRM (and the dog not only does not die, but is an accomplished scam artist), they’re not exactly 100% low-stakes tea-time cozy.
I’d definitely put Discworld somewhere in the middle, but it’s still a comfort read for me too. The low-stakes definition makes cosy fantasy kinda of limiting – even Legends and Lattes, she’s battling someone trying to sabotage her business. It’s more like personal stakes versus societal stakes.
This post cracked me up! 😂 And I love your idea!! Thanks for sharing it!! 😍
I love this idea 😀
I’m definitely going full-on cost at the moment reading Legends & Lattes. I loved Emily Wilde and can’t wait to read the second book in the series. Seeing The Invisible Library here reminds me I need to get back to that series too, I’ve only read the first book but I think I have them all except the last one.
Oh this is awesome Ellie! I love it.
I love this! I tend not to get along with grimdark, although I make an exception for GRRM. I’m probably slightly left of centre, generally…
This is such a fun post! My comfort zone on the cozymeter is somewhere in the middle… not too grim, definitely not too cozy. But I do love a fantasy story where “it’s not about saving the whole world.” (I especially like stories where there may be world saving involved, but it’s not exactly the main feature). NETTLE & BONE was one of my favourite reads last year and I think the spot where you’ve placed it on this scale is just right to represent the type of fantasy reads I enjoy most 😁
What a delightful (imaginary) gadget! My own taste is more on the cosy end of the spectrum and the older I get, the cosier I prefer things.
This is such a delightful idea! Your graphics are so cute <3
I find that the more i grow up, the more i like the cozy side of the spectrum ahah
This is brilliant, I love it! Thanks for sharing.
Great post! I’ve always thought a comfort read means a cozy one, until recently when I considered what are my comfort reads for a Fantastic Fives topic and realized not all the books I chose are cozy. I think my comfort zone on the cozyometer is somewhere in the middle leaning toward the red. I don’t want ALL my favorite characters to die. But I’d like to think the dog did but be reassured by the end.
Hi Ellie, this is such a nice idea! I love cozy fantasy reads, mainly because I want to read some low-concentration reads at the end of day lately that are wholesome and easy to get into. May I use your graphic for future book reviews showing how cozy the read was (with credits ofc)? I think it’s a helpful visual!
Thank you, you’re welcome to use them for your reviews!
[…] of Curiosity Killed the Bookworm has created a Cosyometer to help define the subgenre of cosy fantasy – there’s even a download link so you can […]
[…] The Cosyometer Wyrd and Wonder Journey Tag: Part One Adventures in Discomfort: A Rec List of Disability in Fantasy Bone Swans: Stories by C S E Cooney […]
[…] of My Mind dived into the Wyrd and Wonder map. ⌘ Ellie from Curiosity Killed the Bookworm made The Cosyometer! She also wrote a short story for Wyrd and Wonder. ⌘ Ari from The Book Nook matched their […]
I love this meter! I personally like my books smack dab in the middle. I don’t generally lean towards grim fantasy and it weighs heavily on me but on the other end sometimes it feels like nothing is happening in cosy fantasies? Idk if that’s a me thing or what.
[…] The Cosymeter by Ellie at Curiosity Killed the Bookworm […]